Uncovering the Truth: Painting Over Old Paint vs. Stripping

When it’s time to refresh your living space with a new coat of paint, you might be faced with a common dilemma: should you paint over the existing paint or go through the process of stripping it away? At Buhle Painting and Decorating, we’re here to shed light on this age-old question and help you make an informed decision.

House Painting Winnipeg

Painting Over Old Paint



One of the most significant advantages of painting over old paint is the convenience it offers. It saves you time and effort compared to stripping, which can be a labor-intensive task.


Painting over old paint is typically more cost-effective since it requires fewer materials and less labor. It’s a budget-friendly option for those looking to update their space without breaking the bank.

Suitable for Most Situations

In many cases, painting over existing paint is a viable option, especially if the old paint is in good condition, well-adhered to the surface, and not significantly damaged.


Surface Imperfections

If the old paint has imperfections like cracks, peeling, or uneven texture, painting over it may not effectively hide these flaws. The new paint may accentuate existing issues.

Color Changes

If you’re transitioning from a dark color to a lighter one or vice versa, painting over old paint may require multiple coats to achieve the desired color, which can be time-consuming.


Certain paint types and finishes may not adhere well to the existing paint. It’s essential to ensure compatibility between the old and new paint to prevent adhesion problems.


House Painting Winnipeg

Stripping Old Paint


Surface Restoration

Stripping old paint allows you to start with a clean slate, addressing any surface imperfections and achieving a smooth, even finish.

Complete Color Change​

Stripping old paint allows you to start with a clean slate, addressing any surface imperfections and achieving a smooth, even finish..

Enhanced Durability

Stripped surfaces provide a strong foundation for paint adhesion, which can lead to a more durable and long-lasting finish.



Stripping paint can be a time-consuming and physically demanding task, especially for large areas or intricate surfaces.

Potential Health Risks

Depending on the age of the existing paint, it may contain lead or other hazardous materials. Proper safety precautions must be taken when stripping old paint.

Increased Cost

Stripping paint typically requires the purchase of additional materials, such as paint strippers and tools, which can increase the overall project cost.

The Verdict

The decision to paint over old paint or strip it largely depends on the condition of the existing paint, your desired outcome, and your budget. In many cases, painting over old paint is a practical and cost-effective choice, especially when the existing paint is in good condition. However, for a complete transformation, optimal surface preparation, and long-lasting results, stripping old paint may be the preferred option.


At Buhle Painting and Decorating, we have the expertise to assess your specific situation and provide tailored recommendations. Whether you choose to paint over existing paint or opt for stripping, we ensure a meticulous and professional approach to achieve the stunning results you envision for your space. Contact us today to discuss your painting project, and let’s bring your vision to life.

Joanne Abbott
Joanne Abbott
Read More
The team always arrived on time, kept us updated with progress and did a great job. Very professional, meticulous and a pleasure to work with.
Read More
This was my second time using this company and it won’t be the last. Great experience both times right from quote to project finish. The owner, project manager and painters were all great to deal with. Very friendly and knowledgeable in their field. They made my stucco to look brand new again! Thanks team! We’ll see you soon!
Nancy King
Nancy King
Read More
They were very helpful picking the right paint colour and the paint job looks great with no mess left behind. Very concerned with your satisfaction.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *